« Waking up giggling... and thinking. | Main | Gone fishing »
Thursday, May 11, 2006
Another assumption laid to rest
There's a strongly held belief among many parents that children... especially pre-teens... are incapable of planning and executing complex tasks.
We tell each other over coffee that the personal tools required to sustain endeavors involving multiple participants, external supply lines, logistical support, warehousing capabilities and a host of other long-range multi-tasking skills, are simply beyond the scope of the average pre-teen.
This isn't some unfair assumption... we have empirical data to support our claims.
Earnest promises to clean rooms and pick up dirty laundry made just before dinner are long forgotten by the end of the meal. Expeditions to procure staples such as milk and butter from the corner store are inexplicably diverted to friend's houses and basketball courts.
In short, we understand the demographic of which we speak.
However, in light of recent events, I feel that perhaps this hypothesis of pre-teen ineptitude and goldfish-like recall may have to be reconsidered.
All over Israel, for the past few weeks, well-organized groups of pre-teens have been planning and executing the local equivalent of the Manhattan Project... gathering (and in some cases stealing) and aggregating any combustible material within a 5 kilometer radius of their homes in preparation for the traditional L'ag B'Omer bonfires.
The advanced planning, organizational skills and long-range logistical coordination required to select a suitable site, organize and dispatch workers on daily foraging missions, assign a schedule of guards to safeguard the growing stockpile of wood, purchase foodstuffs and other consumables, and actually bring it all together weeks in the future, is simply a staggering accomplishment for a demographic that has consistently failed to put away clean folded clothes stacked inches from where they sleep!
Yet every day for the past two weeks as I leave Efrat in the morning... and when I return in the evening... everywhere I look I see evidence of these complex projects under way and approaching fruition.
Every empty lot has a growing pile of wood under careful guard. Every street has dozens of youthful workers dragging and carrying fuel towards designated gathering points... and construction sites around town have been picked clean (translation: robbed) of any unsecured lumber and signage.
In the face of such overwhelming evidence I suppose we grown-ups may have to rethink our assumptions about our children's actual ability to multi-task and maintain focus.
Or perhaps - as a friend suggests - it is simply the primal allure of standing around in tribal groups and burning stuff that has kept these easily distracted youngsters focused.
Hmmmm. We may be onto something here. Maybe if I threaten to set fire to their rooms...
Posted by David Bogner on May 11, 2006 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c581e53ef00e5503eac758833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Another assumption laid to rest:
Comments
You don't need to threaten to set fire to their rooms, just offer them the opportunity to do it themselves...
Posted by: Dave (Balashon) | May 11, 2006 2:49:28 PM
I would have *hoped* that in a religious community like Efrat, parents would be more strict about their kids NOT stealing lumber from construction sites. That is outright theft and a violation not only of Israeli law but also of the Torah. If I were building a home in Efrat, or was the contractor, I'd want those kids' families to reimburse me either for the lumber or for the cost of posting a guard in front of the site. That is just *wrong.* Bad, bad middot education! Theft is theft, even it it's "cute."
Posted by: Sarah | May 11, 2006 3:13:21 PM
Dave... Point taken. :-)
Sarah... Whoa, down girl! While I know what you've described occasionally happens, what I was referring to was the kind of scrap lumber one normally finds lying around after they have broken apart the molds they set up for pouring concrete. The can only be used a certain number of times and my neighbor (who is a contractor) has told me that the foraging the kids to at this time of year actually saves him hauling a lot of the scrap wood to the dump. Any contractor worth his salt knows to lock up any usable wood around this time of year.
Posted by: treppenwitz | May 11, 2006 3:30:05 PM
Alright. Sorry about the misunderstanding.
Posted by: Sarah | May 11, 2006 3:51:58 PM
they start really young. two of my kids (under 5th grade) have been at it since pesach ended... it's great! i don't have to worry about getting homework done with them (if you don't do your homework...)and they are outdoors and otherwise occupied all afternoon! whadda country!
Posted by: nikki | May 11, 2006 3:58:37 PM
Perhaps combining the 2 tasks - gathering stuff to burn... cleaning their rooms... i'm seeing a nice 'meshing' of tasks here! However it could get costly having to buy them new furniture and clothes every year, but hey - it's for a good cause! ;)
Posted by: val | May 11, 2006 4:15:32 PM
Maybe if I threaten to set fire to their rooms...
Uh oh, in a couple of hours we are going to start seeing comments about the crazy settlers who tear down trees and burn down houses.
Posted by: Jack | May 11, 2006 4:29:29 PM
Let's take this one step further...perhaps teaching them to "clean and burn" their rooms will lead to a career as a firefighter. It's perfect...they clean their rooms and get a career, all rolled into one.
Posted by: Randi(cruisin-mom) | May 11, 2006 4:43:04 PM
Every year I have the same mixed feelings about Lag B'Omer. On one hand I do love the bonfire (primal indeed), singing and dancing, but I also have a real concern for the ecology since a good portion of the "lumber" being burned is actually MDF/composite board/sandwich/plywood and coated with paint/lacquer/melamine/formica-all toxic. The holiday could be a real chance to educate our children about ecology, but who wants to hear about all that when busy eating scorched hotdogs, hamburgers and potatoes. :)
And yes, especially at this time of year, I am grateful that we live on the seacoast and under breezy conditions we'll be able to open our blinds and windows by 10am the day after the bonfires. :)
Kids' rooms? You actually go in there? You're a brave man, Charlie Brown.
Posted by: jennifer | May 11, 2006 6:14:22 PM
hmm, I like this concept of the bonfire and the messy bedroom. I will need to present the idea carefully - so as not to suggest he simply toss a match in there :)
Posted by: lisa | May 11, 2006 7:34:24 PM
Ha ha! That's a hilarious idea... just make sure the whole house doesn't burn down with the rooms! ; )
Posted by: Irina | May 11, 2006 11:39:33 PM
When kids are focused on something they want, nothing stands in their way. That's why educators need innovative ways to reach kids. When you relate a lesson to their world, it instantly becomes exciting. (and I'm not even a teacher!)
Posted by: Essie | May 12, 2006 5:28:13 AM
I agree with Essie. Kids can accomplish amazing things...but they need to WANT to accomplish them...case in point: My 6 year old daughter actually dragged her butt out of bed at 5:45 this morning to make breakfast for her dad for his birthday. I normally can't pull her out of bed myself before 7, but she had her heart set on having his breakfast done and serving it to him in bed before his alarm went off. I can't get her to pick up a piece of clothing or put her dish in the dishwasher, but she can make a three egg omlet before 6 am... ( with some help from me, of course, but it was impressive none the less!)it's all dependent on how determined they are to reach their goal (not how determined WE are that they reach it!)
Posted by: nrg | May 12, 2006 2:39:59 PM
I watched 3 tiny charedi boys transport a double bed frame along a busy Petach Tikva street the other day- I was reminded of worker ants.
Posted by: PP | May 12, 2006 3:26:03 PM












